Council of State prosecutor once again demands annulment of İstanbul Convention decree

Click to read the article in Turkish / Kurdish 

The Council of State, the top administrative court of Turkey, yesterday (June 7) heard the case filed by 15 organizations against the country's withdrawal from the İstanbul Convention, a Council of Europe treaty on combating violence against women.

The prosecutor demanded the reversal of the president's decree.

Some 200 lawsuits have been filed against President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's 2021 decree pulling Turkey out of the convention.

CLICK - Turkey's withdrawal from İstanbul Convention 'unlawful,' says Council of State prosecutor

CLICK - Council of State prosecutor says Erdoğan decree ditching İstanbul Convention should be revoked

Among those who spoke at the hearing were Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) Co-Chair Pervin Buldan and main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP) Women's Branch Chair Aylin Nazlıaka and MP Özgür Özel, as well as lawyers from women's organizations.

Özel: Exercise your authority in the name of the public

MP Özel said it was not only a "women's issue" but a very important issue for the country, where "constitutional judicial independence is undermined."

* I am here to remind you of your constitutional responsibilities. Article 90 clearly explains the situation regarding international conventions. It says, "International conventions can only be annulled by the parliament."

* I know you have the burden of defending the women who cannot express themselves, women who don't even know they have such a right.

* As the father of a girl, as a man and a citizen of Turkey who is ashamed of every single incident of violence, I hope you will exercise your authority in the name of the public, in the name of women.

'The scene that you didn't see'

Lawyer Şanal Sarıhan said inequality was the reason that the court board comprised six men and one woman.

* The women in front of the Council of State came here from other cities just to follow this hearing. They hugged each other even though they didn't know each other.

* This is the scene of a common demand. It is said that laws are written on the street. The İstanbul Convention was written on the street to protect women's lives.

Buldan: I'm here for all women and LGBTI+s of Turkey

As a plaintiff, HDP Co-Chair Buldan talked about the purpose and the process of the ratification of the convention and stressed its importance for women and LGBTI+s.

* Even though the AKP [the ruling Justice and Development Party] portrayed it as its own success, it is the success of the women's movement of Turkey. This convention provides a great road map to end male violence.

* The convention aims to protect women's children's and LGBTI+s' right to life, shelter and employment. It explains how a systematic struggle against male violence can be built step by step.

"Is the Lanzarote Convention the next?"

Lawyer Hülya Gülbahar also said international conventions can only be repealed by the parliament, citing article 90 of the Constitution.

* We are defending international treaties here, but we are also defending our Constitution.

* They also target the Council of Europe's Lanzarote Convention. The full name of this convention is the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children Against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse. As the women's movement of Turkey, we defend both the İstanbul Convention and this convention. This [court] board has a historic responsibility.

"They don't protect women because there is no convention"

Lawyer Özge Yücel said the unique aspect of the convention is that it is the most binding legal text on the subject and obligates the signatory states to gather data about violence.

* Even if the İstanbul Convention didn't exist, the content of the convention was considered to be among the states' responsibilities according to the human rights law and other human rights conventions.

* The administrative action that is the subject of the case is defective and unlawful not only in terms of the procedures but also of its purpose. It is a decision that does not have any function technically, because the states have to combat violence whether there are conventions or not.

Müjde Tozbey-Erden: "If you approve the annulment of the İstanbul Convention, you will be murderers as well. If you accept this case, you will be among those who protect women. In the name of the Women and Children First Association, I demand the reversal of the decision of cancellation.

CHP's Nazlıaka said the following:

* If I were to ask the friends here, is there anyone who is not worried when they hear footsteps, I think not even a single person would raise their hands. Our group deputy chair (MP Özel) just said he was ashamed of murders. I hear this sentence from men who live humanely: "If there is a woman walking in front of me, I either cross to the other side of the road or walk past her so that she does not feel nervous." We are in a process where freedoms are restricted for everyone, and, more importantly, where women's right to life is threatened.

* The decision you will give is a decision between defending women's right to life and death.

Defending lawyers' statements

After the plaintiffs' statements, the defending attorneys spoke. They demanded the rejection of the case. Emre Topal, a lawyer with the Presidency of International Conventions, claimed that withdrawal from the convention would not cause a problem in terms of human rights.

(EMK/AÖ/VK)