Court dismisses Albayrak's suit against law professor over 'Paradise Papers' articles

President Erdoğan and Serhat Albayrak

Click to read the article in Turkish

The İstanbul 7th Penal Court of First Instance has dismissed a claim for damages by Serhat Albayrak, the head of Turkuvaz Media Group, against Prof. Yaman Akdeniz for sharing an article about the Paradise Papers leak.

Serhat Albayrak, the brother of Berat Albayrak, the former finance minister and President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's son-in-law, alleged that his personel rights were offended and demanded 100,000 lira (11.570 USD) for immaterial damages.

Recalling the access blocking orders issued by penal judgeships of peace for news articles about Albayrak and Paradise Papers, attorney Hakkı Ceyhun Pınar claimed Akdeniz offended Albayrak's personal rights by sharing the content of the orders.

The defense

Making his defense, Akdeniz noted that he is a lawyer and an active social media user and said he shared the court order for with the public.

A member of the Freedom of Expression Association (İFÖD), a group monitoring web censorship, Akdeniz said, "I've been actively using Twitter for years and have been often informing the public especially about the internet, freedom of expression, censorship and decisions of access block and content removal.

"I would also like to state that no lawsuits have been filed against me before, and my works and posts have not been subject to trial before, during the legal struggle I waged for the development of internet and freedom of expression standards, and during the process of informing the public.

"In fact, this first case is about one of my public disclosures. When I saw on Diken.com.tr that access to a report of a case that Serhat Albayrak lost was blocked, I shared this on my Twitter account. Later, access to this tweet was blocked upon an application by the plaintiff. I again shared the access block on my tweet.

"The objection I filed against the access block was rejected by the judgeship. I have filed an individual application with the Constitutional Court. The tweets subject to the case have no relation to offending personal rights. I demand the dismissal of the case."

Announcing its verdict after Akdeniz's defense, the court dismissed the case. It will issue its justified ruling later.

Serhat Albayrak's attorney Hakkı Ceyhun Pınar and Prof. Akdeniz and his attorneys Buse Karataş, Sevgi Kalan Güvercin and Dilara Alpan were present in the courtroom.

Main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP) deputy Sezgin Tanrıkulu and Reporters Without Borders (RSF) Turkey Representative Erol Önderoğlu also followed the hearing.

"The purpose is intimidation"

Speaking to bianet after the hearing, Akdeniz said, "The case was all about eliminating contentious judicial decisions about news reports about the Paradise Papers, publication of which is in the public interest.

"This type of lawsuits are defined as 'strategic lawsuit against public participation' by international civil society organizations.

"The primary purpose of the lawsuits filed by abusing legal proceedings is not to win the case but to intimidate and silence people who inform the public, especially journalists and academics like me, on issues that particularly concern the public."

(HA/VK)