ECHR Condemns Turkey’s Military Discipline Practice

Strasbourg court finds a violation of human rights regarding disciplinary cell containment practice at the Turkish military. The court finds restraining liberties outside the judicial system, unacceptable.


Strasbourg - BIA News Center
11 August 2011, Thursday 09:03

European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) condemned Turkey to damages amounting to 9 000 Euros regarding a disciplinary containment practice -dubbed as 'disco'- by the military.

The Strasbourg court's ruling can set a precedent about the widespread practice, causing fear among regulars doing their compulsory military service and often used as a threat by military commanders.

Restraining of liberty can be ruled only by a court and a procedure of appeal against the decision must be present, the ECHR ruling said.

The ruling brings about questions regarding the Military Criminal Code, former military judge Ümit Kardaş told bianet.

According to Article 171 of the code, superior ranking military officials even have the right to temporarily arrests on grounds of disciplinary action. Kardaş argues that the Military Criminal Code should be scrutinized and abolished.

He says that only military offences such as desertion and disobedience to orders could be included in the Military Criminal Code. On the contrary, the current legislation has duplicated many articles of the Criminal Code, thus rendering them as military offences.

According to Kardaş, stripping disciplinary superior officers from their authority to rule punishments would solve the problem.

"From now on, the ECHR will condemn Turkey in each case regarding this practice. Therefore, it's no longer possible to employ Article 171 of the Military Criminal Code as it will be directly condemned in Strasbourg."

The case in question dates back to 2007, when a soldier left barracks without permission and was condemned to seven days imprisonment according to Article 171. The soldier's appeals against the ruling were turned down by superior officers and he had filed an application to the ECHR. (EK/EÜ)

 

Independent Communication NetworkIndependent Communication Network comprises more than internet news website bianet.org. It is a continuously unfolding network since 1997 and embraces "Training Drives" for journalists and communication students and NGOs; handbook series, "Radio Programs" for the local media, conferences, forums, international exchange programs.

IPS Communication Foundation (BİA)IPS Communication Foundation is the implementing body for the BIA &bianet.org. Founded in 1993 by four journalists and one human rights activists, has implemented many projects including a BİA, BİA2 and BİA3.

BİA LibraryBİA Library comprises of handbooks series and guides and researches which systemize the theoretical and informative contributions realized during the implementation of programs within the BİA projects. Some of the 15 publications are in English and accessible via bianet.org.

Contact usYou can reach IPS Communication Foundation directors, BİA project coordination, bianet.org editorial board via telephone, fax, e-mail and mail from everywhere on the globe, dispatch information and/or documents and request meetings.