The European Court of Human Rights held its annual press conference on Thursday 26 January 2012. On this occasion, Sir Nicolas Bratza, the President of the Court, presented a summary of the Court's activities and its statistics for 2011. He said that the European governments must assume their part of the shared responsibility for the protection of human rights across the continent.
Approximately 151,600 applications were pending before a judicial formation on 1 January 2012. More than half of these applications had been lodged against one of four countries: Russia (26.6 %), Turkey (10.5 %), Italy (9.1 %) and Romania (8.1 %).
In 2011, more than a third of the judgments delivered by the Court concerned four of the Council of Europe's forty-seven member States: Turkey (174), Russia (133), Ukraine (105) and Greece (73). Of the total number of judgments it has delivered in 2011, in over 85% of cases the Court has found at least one violation of the Convention by the respondent State.
The judgements delivered against Turkey were mainly based on applications regarding length of proceeding, right to liberty and security, lack of effective investigation, protection of property, inhuman or degrading treatment, non execution or right to a fair trial.
Criticism by governments should rely on reasoned argument
Court President Sir Nicolas Bratza said at the press conference: "Human rights, the rule of law and justice seem to be slipping down the political agenda in the current economic climate. It is in times like these that we must remember that human rights are not a luxury and that the burden of their protection must be a shared one".
President Bratza explained that the governments' responsibilities included ensuring the proper functioning of the Court. The 30,000 repetitive cases pending before the Court indicated a failure to remedy structural problems in the countries concerned and a collective failure of the implementation process, for which all 47 countries were responsible.
It was also important that its independence and authority should not be undermined and that criticism by governments, even where legitimate, should rely on reasoned argument rather than emotion and exaggeration. (AS/VK)
Related bianet News
"Turkey Takes Lead in Violations of Freedom of Expression" 30 November 2011ECHR judge Karakaş said that among all member states of the Council of ...
THOMAS HAMMARBERG "Systematic Dysfunctions in the Turkish Justice System" 19 October 2011Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, Thomas Hammarberg, criticized that lengthy trial ...
50 YEARS OF ECHR ECHR: 9 out of 10 Cases in Turkey Unjust 18 September 2009Out of a total of 97,300 cases in the hands of the ECHR ...
Most Read Today
Request for Release of Pastor Brunson Rejected Again 17 August 2018
Trump: We’re Cutting Back on Turkey 17 August 2018
HDP’s Gülsüm Ağaoğlu Released 17 August 2018