The Istanbul 2nd Criminal Court of First Instance sentenced journalist Nazlı Ilıcak to imprisonment of eleven months and 20 days under charges of "insult via the media" of Judge Osman Kaçmaz from the Sincan district of Ankara. The sentence was suspended.
Ilıcak from Sabah newspaper wrote a column entitled "The President's Immunity", published on 25 May 2009. The journalist had accused Judge Osman Kaçmaz from the Sincan 1st High Criminal Court of behaving officiously and in an ideological manner. Kaçmaz intended to sue President Abdullah Gül in the context of an investigation into "lost millions", a corruption case in the 1990s.
Writing about "officiousness" regarded as criminal offence
Ilıcak wrote, "The judge form Sincan might behave ideologically; or as far as his conscience is concerned, he believed that immunity did not apply to Gül. But anyhow, looking at the discussion started off in the country, he says 'That's the last thing we needed' and at least I want to emphasize Osman Kaçmaz's officiousness".
Sentenced to five years of silence
Ilıcak was not present at the hearing when Court Judge Sevim Efendiler claimed that she had "exceeded the limits of criticism".
Efendiler initially decreed for a two years and two months' prison sentence under article 125 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK) on defamation. The sentence was then mitigated to eleven months and 20 days imprisonment.
The judge decided for a "probation period" for the writer of five years. If Ilıcak "does not deliberately commit the same kind of crime" within this period, the sentence will not be enforced.
"Lost billions" case
Welfare Party leaders were accused of embezzling around one trillion lira, i.e. one million lira in today's currency (approx. € 476,000). Party chair Necmettin Erbakan and 78 party leaders were accused of forging documents and were tried. Erbakan was sentenced to two years four months imprisonment. 68 party officials received prison sentences of up to one year and two months. The Supreme Court of Appeals ratified the sentences.
Because Gül had parliamentary immunity at the time, no criminal case was opened against him. When his term ended, the file was considered again, but the Ankara Chief Public Prosecution decided to drop the case. Following the objection of Cahit Nalbantoğlu, a former member of the Supreme Court of Appeals, the Sincan court has decreed a possible trial. (EÖ/VK)
Related bianet News
FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION Caricatursit Özdabak Faces 20,000 TL Compensation Claim 16 February 2010Illustrator Halil İbrahim Özdabak from Yeni Asya newspaper is tried with a TL ...
Ankara Court Rules that President Gül May Be Tried 20 May 2009President Abdullah Gül is facing a possible trial for a corruption scandal a ...
Most Read Today
Deniz Yücel: I don’t Know Why I’ve Been Released 19 February 2018
Deniz Yücel and His Friends Granted ‘Journalist of the Year’ Award 19 February 2018
2 Soldiers Die in Syria, Hakkari 19 February 2018
Reuters: Syrian Army to Enter Afrin 19 February 2018
Regional Court Overturns HDP MP’s Prison Sentence 19 February 2018